There’s a song called Stuck In The Middle With You, by a band called Stealers Wheel. Although I recognise the song there isn’t a snowball’s chance in hell that I would have ever guessed the name of the band. I don’t get the name choice. Either they picked two random words, or the bass player saw a car one day with very cool rims and decided that if he had a jack and the right sized socket, then that car had stealer wheels.
I don’t know what to call that particular theft. It sounds kind of sketchy if you’re describing it to a friend. Yeah I saw her on the street and she was gorgeous so I jacked her up and gave her a rim job.
And once I started thinking about the name I was drawn into this rabbit hole of two random words. It took me a while to find my way out as I contemplated a career naming new bands. The process is actually tougher than you’d think, because if you stretch the concept then it’s possible to have glass concrete or a sausage tuba. Not likely, but possible. So that’s the reason I was jammed up in the rabbit hole for as long as I was.
Anyway, the lyrics to the song make no fucking sense, and so I was forced to hit the google to make it make sense. Turns out that Gerry Rafferty wrote the tune, and it was about making the big time and having to attend a signing party with music executives who spent the entire dinner kissing the ass of the Label’s chief executive. So now that the message is clarified, there’s one line that I really like. Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right, here I am, stuck in the middle with you. Gerry does not however mention whom he was stuck in the middle with. Also I’m thinking he was really high, because he mentions both sleeping on the floor, not knowing how he was going to get down the stairs, and being afraid of falling off his chair.
I hate being stuck in the middle.
It’s kind of ok if you have authority. Like a judge or an arbitrator. It’s not as ok if you’re in a position where you’re trying to negotiate a compromise. Like a mediator. And it’s a fucking disaster waiting to happen if we’re talking about friends or family. I guess it’s a little easier with family because you didn’t choose those people to be around you, and so if one of them is an asshole, you don’t have any responsibility for that asshole being present. But if it’s two friends then you chose them as companions. It wasn’t a biological obligation, and so if you confirm that one of your choices is an asshole, then it’s likely that friendship is going to see some duress. Too much of that and you’re looking at a friendship termination. Not to mention that if this is a regular occurrence then maybe it’s a good idea to hold a review of your friend picking process. You can also terminate a family relationship. But it takes longer, and it generally involves more than one disagreement. Plus the proximity arrangement means there’s lots more opportunity for awkward moments at family gatherings.
Part of the shittiness of being the middleman or woman is that you have too much information. Both parties to the dispute have told you their side of the story. That story describes in detail why they believe that the other person is an asshole. So when you go back to talk with the other half of the problem you have to make a decision about how much you’re going to want to reveal. Because you then become the bearer of bad news, and whether we like it or not, the messenger gets shot often enough that the idiom exists.
Assuming you have any interest in resolving the issue, and still staying friends with everyone involved, you then have to try and dance around mediating a dispute without disclosing details that will just make the situation worse.
Unless you’re a pretend middleman.
These people are absolute pricks. They pretend that they want a resolution, but in reality they tremble with excitement over being in possession of enough weaponry to be able to control the eventual outcome. I think they absolutely adore telling person A what person B said ,and the longer they can prolong the disagreement the more powerful they feel, because they’re the conduit that the information flows through. They feel needed.
Basically these people are shit disturbers, and are exactly the kind of messengers that inspired the don’t shoot adage. Everyone knows at least one of these people, but for some odd reason we seem to have trouble identifying them. They appear genuine but they have a commonality that distinguishes them from a true middleman, and once you know what to look for they’re easy to identify.
They create the problem or they exploit the problem. It’s actually a talent. I worked with a guy once who possessed this particular skill. I shall name him Mike. Mike loved any and all kinds of dirt. Mike also promptly shared that dirt with the dirty person and named who had given him the information. It was a terrible idea to tell Mike anything even slightly opiniated. I used to feed him bullshit just to see him run with it. Eventually Mike caught on and was less inclined to believe anything I told him. This was a good way to deal with the Mikes of the world. Eventually they look stupid enough times that they stop trying to be the middleman of manufactured animosity.
Genuine middlemen are much more pure of heart than the Mike’s. They want to broker a peace agreement that’s sustainable, and it’s a tricky business. I think that fairly often the intermediary ends up disliked by both of the factions. In some ways this is actually a success. It’s one of those bargaining situations where neither party is entirely pleased with the end result, but equal displeasure is a parity that everyone can live with and they blame the middleman instead of each other.
So it’s risky. Also once both factions have identified you as a suitable mediator it’s entirely within the realm of possibilities that both of them will end up being pissed off with you, and you lose two friends because you got involved.
Another downside to being a middleman is staying in the middle. Plenty of situations occur where the mediator has to deal with the fact that one of the parties is a lunatic. So, instead of remaining impartial you end up picking a side. Once that happens the side that didn’t get picked isn’t your friend anymore. In fact, in most instances the person you didn’t side with ends up disliking you as much or more than the original sparring partner.
That’s the main problem with friends and family disputes. It’s really tough to be a neutral party because you’ve been witness to all the shit that led up to the need for a middleman. Odds are that you might have been involved in one way or another in a few previous disagreements between the two combatants and that involvement skews your impartiality.
Kind of like Hezbollah trying to broker a peace deal with the Israeli’s and Hamas or Al- Qaeda, or Islamic State, or Ansar Allah or Saraya-al Quds.
So I think that I’m going to moderate my approach if I find myself being drawn into a middleman situation. Make the situation more official by having both parties agree to my middleman position. Once that happens you inherit some semblance of authority to go with the responsibility. Because if one or both ends of the argument are just going to fight with you than all you’ve accomplished is turning a twosome into a threesome.
That’s what Mike wants.
I don’t want to be like Mike.